AdvantageClub.ai
Blog
How to make an Incentive Program more Engaging
Author img

Kartikay Kashyap

May 1, 2025

Blog Hero
Table of Contents
Join our community

Employee incentives have been a part of corporate culture for a long time now. However, in spite of these incentives, employees aren’t really engaged at their workplace. As per the Gallup report, 77% of employees around the world are not engaged at their workplace, and about half (51%) intend to quit their jobs. Why do we have this situation?

Companies are still finding it difficult to create a robust incentive or rewards program for their employees that is more impactful and strong enough to increase talent retention in their organization.

How Technology can Help

Many companies are moving ahead toward digitization. In today’s time, technology can help companies make their processes more efficient and create a better impact in engaging their employees. Digitization has played a vital role in enhancing employee engagement levels regarding rewards and recognition. 

How can Digitization make Incentives More Engaging?

What makes an incentive program less impactful? Traditional ways of incentivizing employees have some flaws, which do not give the desired results to the employer. Keeping rewards uniform for all, not enough recognition for employees, and having only cash rewards as an incentive are some shortcomings that can reduce the impact of an incentive program, resulting in more disengaged employees who are also more likely to leave when they get another opportunity.

Some practical solutions:

1. Freedom of Choosing How to Get Rewarded
A digitized R&R platform allows employees the freedom to choose how they want to be rewarded or how they want to redeem their rewarded points. During the festive season or when reaching a particular milestone, such as an anniversary or birthday, employees can choose their gift. If rewarded through points, they can redeem their awarded points on their choice of products or brands. This gives the employees flexibility.

2. Point-Based Rewards Act as Long-Term Incentive Design
A point-based reward, or incentive program encourages employees to save and accrue points and use them as a long-term benefit tool to invest them in better experiences or products. Otherwise, cash rewards are exhausted almost immediately by employees.

3. Non-Monetary Recognition
An R&R platform like AdvantageClub.ai also allows peer-to-peer recognition among employees, which can happen anytime and anywhere using digital badges and customizable notes. Coupled with a monetary incentive program, non-monetary appreciation builds a positive culture and leads to more engaged employees.

4. Nudges Act Like Motivators
AdvantageClub.ai’s automated sales incentive program also constantly nudges sales professionals to achieve their goals, which acts like a constant reminder for them and, moreover, becomes a motivating factor to enhance their performance as they can keep their focus on their goals at all times.

5. Instant Gratification
R&R platforms allow employees to experience instant gratification rather than waiting for their reward for another financial cycle. Gen Zs are more used to getting rewarded now and then, and R&R platforms like AdvantageClub.ai can help employers keep today’s young workforce engaged.

Measuring the Effectiveness of Incentive Programs

We are all aware of how powerful employee incentive programs are. Implementing an incentive program is one thing, but measuring its impact is also important. If we do not measure the impact of our employee incentive program, it would be difficult to fix existing bugs, manage resource allocation, and improve. All that will remain is a ‘tick in the box activity.’

Defining clear goals

Before measuring the incentive program’s ROI (Return On Investment), we need to define what we want to achieve out of this incentive program. Was it about increasing sales, enhancing productivity, improving customer satisfaction or reducing employee turnover? We have to set SMART (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound) goals to measure the overall impact.

Quantifying the impact

Giving quantifiable metrics depicting the impact of any program makes it more relevant. After all, we are all in a business, and measuring the impact through numbers builds credibility. For instance, if the goal of the incentive program was to reduce employee turnover, then we can measure how many employees left the company after the program was implemented.

Non-financial impact

Any designed incentive program will not just deliver quantifiable results. It also impacts the workforce in various other ways. For instance, it affects overall employee engagement levels, which companies can measure through employee surveys. Moreover, it can also lead to behavior change, such as increased collaboration or skill-building activity.

Cost and return analysis

We can also measure how much the company invested in the employee incentive program and what exactly we were able to achieve with that investment. For instance, if the goal was to reduce employee turnover, how much cost could the company save on retaining key employees and compare that to the investment? In the same way, one can do this cost analysis process with respect to other defined goals.

Implementing a robust employee incentive program

Implementing an incentive program can be explained in multiple stages. It is important to follow a flow when implementing an employee incentive program.

Setting a Goal

Before implementing an employee incentive program, one should know why they are doing it and what they want to achieve. The objectives or goals can range from reducing absenteeism and employee attrition to increasing productivity and boosting sales revenue. One should have at most three objectives or goals.

Identifying the audience

When building any program involving engagement, we should know our target audience. Knowing the audience and identifying their preferences sets the tone for whether the program will be successful or not. For instance, in the case of an employee incentive program, what should be the reward? What can really drive someone? One needs to find these answers by doing thorough research.

Structure and budget

In this stage, we should decide upon the program’s design. Would you like to gamify it by adding leaderboards and making it transparent for all? Or would you like to manually collate the data and announce the winner after the program ends? Moreover, the program’s budget depends on how it is designed and structured and what elements are used to make it more successful.

Communication

Deciding upon the communication channel on how one wants to announce the winners. Will it be through personalized mail or more like a social recognition where the winners are recognized in front of their colleagues?

Evaluation

Tracking the success of the program through pre-decided metrics on the objectives of the program is one way to evaluate the success. Moreover, what was the engagement level and the response of the participants in the program are other metrics that can give an initial mood of the program.

Plugging in Technology

As part of the designing process, one can consider implementing digital tools such as an employee recognition platform like AdvantageClub.ai, where companies can develop various exciting incentive programs with the help of digital points which can be redeemed for the reward of choice. This would add a gamified element for more engagement, and moreover, digital programs would also provide better metrics to evaluate the success of the program, which would be more accurate.

Addressing common Pitfall

Sometimes, the approach to implementing an employee incentive program may not be sound. We sometimes forget that we are dealing with humans and their emotions, not robots. There are some things we should keep in mind that can fail our employee incentive program.

Money is the only motivator

At times, we think that money is the only thing that motivates an employee. But in many cases, when we are dealing with a knowledgeable workforce, money is not a primary driver for them. For some, it can be flexibility or work-life balance. For instance, we can look at reducing absenteeism by reducing sick leaves. As a reward, we can rather give extra day-offS or remote working opportunities instead of a monetary reward.

More stress, Less motivation

We cannot be bullish when it comes to driving an incentive program. It is not about driving revenue. As HR professionals, we should encourage employees to do their best to participate in employee incentive programs, but we cannot be too aggressive. This way, the program becomes more stressful and fails to attract more engagement.

No rewards means less motivation

Yes, the ones who win and receive rewards are motivated. But what about those who did not get anything? We should recognize their participation and support for the program. We can do this by having participation recognitions such as certificates.

Competition fosters toxicity

Though it is a competition, it needs to be driven by a different approach. Employees should be encouraged to give their best and perform well. Pinning employees against each other may not be a good idea. It can lead to heartburn and toxicity.
Retaining good talent and rewarding employees for their performance are serious issues that companies are concerned about today. Many progressive companies have realized that talent or their people are one of their greatest assets. And to retain them requires a robust incentive program.