Blog
7 Engagement Killers: Spot and Manage Toxic Employee Behaviors in Your Team

Team AdvantageClub.ai
April 17, 2025

Table of Contents
Join our community
In the fast-moving corporate environment, employee engagement is the driving force that gets teams pumped up, productive, and performing at their best. Even in the most dynamic and open offices, though, there are engagement killers – the toxic employees who can bring down your team’s energy, productivity, and happiness. These guys can make a positive work environment a stressful and downbeat place to be.
But how do you detect those toxic employees and manage them wisely? Let us find out how to spot these behaviors, know their negative impacts, and pick up useful methods of managing toxic employees. In this article, we are going to talk about the 7 signs of a toxic employee, the harm they can bring, and how to deal with them wisely to keep your team’s engagement and workplace health intact.
Understanding Toxic Employees
Toxic employees are not small annoyances within your team; they are a major threat to the very fabric of your workplace dynamics. But what is a toxic employee precisely? These are people who exhibit behaviors that generate negativity and conflict in the workplace. They may consistently exhibit resistance, blame others, or spread negativity that affects their co-workers and the overall environment.
These actions by toxic workers can profoundly impact employee engagement. As noted in a study released on the NCBI, a toxic workplace damages employee engagement both directly and indirectly. It impacts organizational support systems and employees’ overall well-being. When employees operate within a toxic culture, negative emotions tend to spread quickly, leading to a chain reaction of low morale, dissatisfaction, and disengagement among team members.
Signs of Toxic Employees
Early identification of toxic employees is important for sustaining a healthy work environment. Some typical signs to look out for are:
- Constant Negativity: Toxic employees are typically perpetually negative. They whine about the work, colleagues, or policies of the organization, pulling the entire team's morale down.
- Blame-Shifting: Such employees always shy away from admitting their errors. They blame someone else or a situation for their failure, resulting in an atmosphere of avoidance and distrust.
- Rumour-Mongering and Gossiping: Gossiping and spreading rumors are among the common behaviors of toxic employees. Rumour-mongering and gossiping contribute to the breakdown of trust and heighten tensions between team members, such that no one is able to concentrate on their job.
- Disengagement: Toxic employees can become disengaged in their jobs, not performing goals and leaning on others to compensate. This results in hard-working employees resenting the extra load.
- Power and Control: Certain toxic employees have dominance over coworkers, playing politics within the work environment. This leads to a toxic work environment in which team members feel undervalued and underappreciated.
- Masking Inadequacies: Backstabbing and belittling can be employed by toxic employees as a protective mechanism to steer attention away from their own incompetence. This tends to create an atmosphere of insecurity and fear where employees remain defensive all the time.
- Undermining Competitors: Treating co-workers as competitors instead of teammates, toxic employees might carry out negative behaviors to sabotage and undermine their fellow workers' achievements. This sets up a hostile environment where there is competition instead of collaboration.
7 Types of Toxic Employees - Behaviors
Toxic employees take many forms with their own personal brand of disruptive behavior. These are seven types of toxic employees you could have in the workplace:
- The Bulldozer: This worker interrupts repeatedly, hijacks conversations, and pushes over others to achieve their objectives. They exercise power in the early stages and repeatedly, making it challenging for other people to share their ideas. These employees use their muscle power to bully others and get their work done whenever they wish.
- The Gossip: Gaining a kick out of sharing rumors and office gossip, this employee fosters distrust and tension within the team. Their behavior can bring about a breakdown in trust and greater tension so that the team cannot perform as a cohesive unit.
- The Underperformer: This worker is disconnected from his/her job, doesn’t meet expectations, and leans on others to cover for them. His/her lack of accountability can result in resentment among high-performing workers who feel overworked.
- The Micromanager: This worker requires to manage each detail, with the result of no autonomy or trust among co-workers. Constantly needing to supervise every feature of a project can result in a suffocating atmosphere in which creativity and innovation are extinguished.
- The Credit Stealer: This worker steals credit from others, causing resentment and a lack of appreciation for diligent employees. Their behavior can demotivate team members and foster a culture of distrust.
- The Passive-Aggressive: This worker employs subtle sniping and veiled barbs to erode trust and build a toxic environment. Their passive-aggressive behavior can cause team members to struggle with open and honest communication.
- The Negative Nancy: This worker is always negative, griping about assignments, co-workers, or corporate policy. Their negativity can dampen the mood of the entire staff, causing it to become harder for all of them to stay motivated and involved.
Managing Toxic Employees
Managing toxic employees is an exercise in prevention and intervention. Here are some ways to help you manage toxic employees:
- Identification: Identify toxic employee behavior in the initial stage. Observe employee interaction and communication style to identify signs of potential toxic behavior.
- Open Communication: Invite all employees to give feedback on team dynamics and issues. Foster an atmosphere where workers will not hesitate to voice concerns and experiences. To learn how to give constructive feedback, use employee feedback examples.
- Structured Conversations: Hold one-on-one sessions to talk about toxic behavior in person. Share direct, honest feedback and establish specific expectations for change. Toxic employees often display mean behavior; they have a ‘put-down’ attitude and go out of their way without taking care of their moral responsibility.
- Clear Expectations: Set and communicate clear expectations of behavior. Make sure that all employees are aware of the conduct standards and the repercussions of toxic behavior.
- Support Systems: Offer resources like counseling or coaching to assist toxic employees in improving. Providing support can make positive changes in behavior and allow them to reintegrate into the team.
- Documentation: Maintain meticulous records of toxic behavior and the actions taken to intervene. Documentation is important for reasons of accountability and, if needed, in making difficult personnel decisions.
- Decisive Action: When behavior doesn’t change even with interventions, be ready to take the necessary action, including reassignment or dismissal, to safeguard the well-being of the team.
To recognize the signs of a bad HR department or any other department, it is important to notice toxic employees and their unpleasant behavior.
The Role of Employee Experiences
Employee experiences are important in addressing toxic employees and improving engagement. Here’s how:
- Employee Rewards: AI prompts and digital rewards can assist in addressing toxic employees by rewarding desired behaviors. Rewards and recognition for employees who engage in positive behaviors can motivate other employees to imitate them, fostering a culture of respect and appreciation for each other.
- Wellness Solutions: Tailored wellness solutions can treat the underlying causes of toxic behavior, including stress and personal problems. By equipping employees with the tools and resources they require to maintain their well-being, you can assist them in overcoming the obstacles that might be driving their toxic behavior.
- AI-Powered Engagement: AI-driven engagement platforms can facilitate real-time execution with smooth conversations, creating a positive work culture. These platforms can give you rich insights into the behavior of employees and assist you in recognizing issues early.
Transform Your Engagement Killers
Toxic employees can pose a serious risk to your team’s morale and well-being. But by catching the signs early, knowing the various types of toxic employees, and taking proactive steps in management, you can minimize their effects and create a healthier, more productive work environment. The secret to managing toxic employees is to confront their behavior directly, establish clear expectations, and offer the support and resources they need to change.
So, take a first step today and begin to identify the engagement killers in your organization. By making the right effort, you can turn your workplace around and establish a culture where everyone succeeds. And if you want a means to effectively handle toxic employees and improve engagement, consider looking up Advantageclub.ai. This engagement platform powered by AI can help you with the information and resources required to build a positive work culture and maintain your team engaged and motivated.